Earlier this week the House Ways and Means Committee released 881 pages of a proposed bill that would make many changes to income, estate and gift taxes. I covered changes to the Estate and Gift Tax system in an earlier post titled Estate Tax Law Changes - What To Do Now with the assistance of my colleague, Brandon Ketron, and now we are back again to cover proposed income tax changes.
As we wait to see what changes will be made in the bill before it can satisfy a majority of US Senators and Vice President Harris, or if any substantial bill will be passed this year, the following is a brief summary of some of the most significant income tax changes, effective dates, as well as thoughts on what to do and what not to do. As the Senate gets involved, all of the following proposals are subject to change, although we should not expect to see anything more taxpayer unfriendly than as the bill currently stands.
We will touch on some of these proposed changes in a free Webinar that we will be giving on Saturday at 11 am. You can sign up by e-mailing to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Income Tax Rate Increases and Rate Bracket Adjustments
One of the most discussed propositions is the increase in income tax rates, bringing individual tax rates to 39.6% for ordinary income. This new rate applies to married individuals who file jointly with taxable income over $450,000, to heads of household with taxable income over $425,000, to unmarried individuals with taxable income over $400,000, to married individuals filing separate returns with taxable income over $225,000, and to trusts and estates with taxable income over $12,500, as adjusted for inflation in future tax years.
In addition to the tax rate increases, the rate brackets will also be adjusted and those on the upper end of the 32% and 35% rate brackets may see a tax rate increase as a result.
These increases will only apply to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2021 so earn as much as you can while you can at our present historically low rates, keeping in mind that you may also pay much more in income taxes because of the limitations on the 20% Section 199A Qualified Business deduction, a 3% surcharge on ultra high earners, and the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax that will now apply to active business income for high earners, as described below. Put together, these changes will have a profound impact on high earners and the motivation to keep on earning. An ultra high earner subject to the surcharge could end up with a tax rate of 46.4%. Add that to a 13% state income tax for a California resident and the tax rate is close to 60%.
25% Capital Gain Rate
The maximum capital gains are taxed would also increase, from 20% to 25%. This new rate will be effective for sales that occur on or after Sept. 13, 2021, and will also apply to Qualified Dividends. The present rate of 20% will continue to apply to any gains and losses incurred prior to September 13, 2021, as well as any gains that originate from transactions entered into under binding written contracts prior to September 13, 2021. Therefore, gains from sales before September 13, 2021 that are reported under the installment method, even if received after September 13, 2021, will still be taxed at the 20% rate when received in the later part of 2021 and in future years as long as the sale took place before September 13, 2021 or the sale takes place on or after September 13, 2021 and was pursuant to a binding written contract that was entered into prior to September 13, 2021.
Expansion of the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax
As noted above, the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax under Internal Revenue Code Section 1411 would be changed to expand the definition of net investment income to include any income derive in the ordinary course of business for single filers with greater than $400,000 in taxable income ($500,000 for joint filers) effective January 1, 2022. Under current law, the 3.8% tax generally only applies to passive investment income (interest, dividends, gain on the sale of stock, etc.)
It is noteworthy that the Net Investment Income Tax applies to trusts and estates beginning at $ 13,050 of income in 2021 and that threshold will be slightly higher each year. Therefore most trusts and estates that have ownership of profitable businesses or ownership interests in profitable entities taxed as partnerships will be subject to the 3.8% tax unless the income received is paid out to beneficiaries, in which event the beneficiaries will be subject to tax as if they received it. S corporation income received by a trust that has made what is called an ESBT (“Electing Small Business Trust”) election are taxed at the highest bracket on K-1 income from the S corporation regardless of whether it is distributed and will also be subject to the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax. Many trusts may sell S corporation ownership interests to beneficiaries who are in lower brackets.
A New 3% Surcharge on High Income Individuals, Trusts and Estates
Effective January 1, 2022 a 3% tax will apply on individual taxpayers to the extent that they have Adjusted Gross Income (“AGI”) in excess of $5,000,000 ($2,500,000 if married filing separately), and on trust and estate income in excess of $100,000 per trust or estate.
Since this tax applies to AGI in excess of the applicable threshold, AGI includes ordinary and capital gains, and is not reduced by charitable deductions (or any other itemized deduction). The time when this would likely apply to most taxpayers is when a business, or other large asset, is sold for a large gain. Savvy planners may consider selling to a related party under the installment method to spread out the gain over multiple tax years, although this would have to be done more than two years prior to the liquidation event to avoid acceleration of the gain when sold to a third party. Planners might also consider transferring interests that may be sold to a charitable remainder trust which can be used to spread income out over a number of years in order to avoid AGI in excess of the threshold.
This is a much bigger issue for trusts because the tax would apply to trust income in excess of $100,000, which will make distributions of Distributable Net Income (DNI) to reduce a trust’s remaining taxable income even more important. In overly simplified terms, when a trust makes a distribution of income to a beneficiary, the beneficiary will pay the tax on such income, and the trust will receive a deduction to reduce its taxable income. Fortunately, the 3% tax will only apply to the extent that income in excess of $100,000 remains in the trust after taking into account distributions made to the beneficiaries. Drafters of trust documents should take a close look at the applicable Principal and Income Act of the situs of the trust to confirm whether capital gains are treated as principal (and thus not distributable) or income. Most states permit trust documents to specify that a fiduciary will have the power to treat capital gains as income that can be distributed to beneficiaries and escape the additional 3% tax, distributed to its beneficiaries.
Small Businesses Will Pay More Taxes In 2022
The bill would also change the 21% flat corporate income tax on ‘C Corporations” to an 18% tax on the company’s net income of up to $400,000, a 21% tax on net income up to $5,000,000, and a 26% tax on net income in excess of $5,000,000. This is still much lower than what the corporate tax rates were before the 2017 tax cuts, and many S corporations will be converted to C corporations if this Act passes, especially given the 3.8% Medicare tax that would be imposed on S corporation flow through income for high earners.
High income individuals who claim the 20% 199A deduction for qualified business income deductions will be disappointed to learn about the proposed maximum deduction of $500,000 for joint returns, $400,000 for individual returns, $250,000 for a married individual filing a separate return, and $10,000 for a trust or estate. This is in addition to the permanent removal of excess business losses for non-corporate taxpayers.
All of the aforementioned business tax changes will be effective after December 31, 2021.
The IRS vs. Over $10,000,000 IRA/Pension Holders
In an effort to combat the hoarding of assets in massive IRA accounts, those who hold Roth and traditional IRA and retirement plan accounts with a combined balance that exceeds $10 million as of the end of a taxable year may not make further contributions if the account holder has taxable income over $400,000, or married taxpayers filing jointly with taxable income over $450,000.
These large account holders will be required to make a minimum distribution equal to “50% of the amount by which the individual’s prior year aggregate tradition IRA, Roth IRA, and defined contribution account balance exceeds the $10 million limit”. Even more extreme treatment will apply to those who have over $20,000,000 in combined accounts.
Furthermore, a loophole that allowed indirect funding of Roth IRAs by the “backdoor Roth” technique could be eliminated for high earners.
What About Charity?
Charitable gifting does not seem to be impacted, except for what we call Grantor Charitable Lead Annuity Trusts, and with higher income tax brackets charities may receive more in donations, which would be good for charitable causes and those who work for charities. It may be time to set up the family foundation you have been considering and get it funded if you will be a high earner next year.
The use of Charitable Remainder Trusts will be more popular to spread large gains over multiple tax years in order to avoid crossing applicable income thresholds. That being said, some of the new provisions are applied based on Adjusted Gross Income (“AGI”) thresholds, and since AGI is determined prior to deductions for charitable contributions (or any other itemized deduction) large charitable donations will not prevent taxpayers from being subject to some of the new taxes on high earners.
Other changes proposed changes in the bill that are noteworthy include the following:
Planning to Plan
Once we have all of the aforementioned in mind, we can begin to plan, while also recognizing that what actually occurs is likely to change.
Here are some examples of planning moves that may be considered at this time:
That being the case, cash method taxpayers may accelerate income by transferring accounts receivable in late December, so that they become taxable, and may wish to defer the payment of expenses until 2022.
It is important to remember that there are advisors and others who stand to gain economically by making recommendations and implementing changes that may backfire on their clients, so caution is advised. For many individuals and families, the best thing to do is to get all of the information and documentation organized, and to see a reputable tax advisor in order to be farther up in line to get properly positioned once changes are (if they are) ratified.
The following summary may help:
The coming months will undoubtedly see plenty of concerned people concerned about protecting their income and assets from taxation. This will spur taxpayers across the country to reacquaint themselves with their estate planners and CPA’s, and motivate people to schedule their annual financial check-up.